How to Contest a Will in South Africa: Grounds, Process & Your Rights

Can You Contest a Will in South Africa?

Yes, you can contest (challenge) a will in South Africa—but only on specific legal grounds. You cannot simply dispute a will because you're unhappy with what you received or were left out entirely.

Contesting a will is a formal legal process that can be emotionally and financially draining. Before you begin, it's essential to understand whether you have valid grounds and the realistic chances of success.

Key Point: In South African law, a testator (the person who made the will) has freedom of testation—the right to leave their assets to whomever they choose. This freedom is protected, which means courts don't easily overturn wills.

Who Can Contest a Will?

Not everyone can challenge a will. You must have legal standing, meaning you have a direct and substantial interest in the estate. This typically includes:

Beneficiaries named in the current will
Beneficiaries named in a previous will who were excluded from the new one
Heirs who would inherit under intestate succession (if there was no will)
Creditors of the deceased with outstanding debts
Surviving spouses or minor children with potential maintenance claims

If you're not directly affected by the will's terms, you generally cannot contest it.

Legal Grounds for Contesting a Will

There are five main grounds on which a will can be challenged in South Africa:

1. Lack of Testamentary Capacity

The testator must have been of sound mind when making the will. This means they understood:

The nature of making a will
The extent of their assets
Who their beneficiaries are
The consequences of their decisions

Common challenges include:

Dementia or Alzheimer's disease
Mental illness
Severe cognitive impairment
Influence of medication or substances

Evidence required: Medical records, doctor's testimony, statements from people who interacted with the testator near the time of signing.

2. Undue Influence or Coercion

A will must reflect the testator's free and voluntary wishes. If someone pressured, manipulated, or coerced the testator into making specific decisions, the will can be challenged.

Signs of undue influence:

Sudden, unexplained changes to the will
A new beneficiary who isolated the testator from family
The testator being dependent on or afraid of someone
Dramatic shifts benefiting those in positions of trust or care

Important: You must prove that the testator's free will was overborne—not just that someone had influence over them.

3. Fraud or Forgery

A will is invalid if:

The testator's signature was forged
The will was fraudulently altered after signing
The testator was tricked into signing (e.g., told it was a different document)
False information was used to influence the testator's decisions

Evidence required: Forensic handwriting analysis, document examination, witness testimony about irregularities.

4. Improper Execution (Failure to Meet Legal Formalities)

South Africa's Wills Act 7 of 1953 sets strict requirements for a valid will:

| Requirement | What the Law Requires | |-------------|----------------------| | Writing | The will must be in writing (handwritten or typed) | | Signature | The testator must sign on every page and at the end | | Witnesses | Two competent witnesses (at least 14 years old) must be present | | Witness Signatures | Witnesses must sign in the presence of the testator and each other | | Age | The testator must be at least 16 years old |

If any of these formalities are not met, the will may be invalid.

Note: Courts can sometimes "condone" (forgive) minor non-compliance if satisfied the document was intended as the person's will—but this is not guaranteed.

5. Revocation or Superseded Will

A will can be contested if:

The testator revoked it before death (verbally or in writing)
A newer valid will exists that supersedes it
The will was destroyed with the intention of revoking it

The Process of Contesting a Will: Step by Step

Step 1: Consult an Estate Attorney

Before taking any action, speak with a specialist estate attorney. They will assess:

Whether you have valid grounds
Your chances of success
The likely costs and timeframes
Alternative solutions (like negotiation)

Step 2: Lodge a Caveat with the Master's Office

If the estate hasn't been finalized, your attorney can lodge a caveat (formal objection) with the Master of the High Court. This:

Puts the Master on notice of your objection
May pause the estate administration
Creates an official record of your dispute

Step 3: Gather Evidence

Strong evidence is crucial. Depending on your grounds, you may need:

Medical records (for incapacity claims)
Witness statements (for undue influence)
Forensic analysis (for forgery claims)
Previous versions of the will
Communication records (emails, letters, messages)

Step 4: Attempt Negotiation or Mediation

Before going to court, consider resolving the matter through:

Direct negotiation with other beneficiaries
Mediation with a neutral third party

This can save significant time, money, and family relationships.

Step 5: Court Proceedings

If negotiation fails, your attorney will institute proceedings in the High Court. The court will:

Hear evidence from all parties
Consider expert testimony
Make a ruling on the will's validity

Possible outcomes:

The will is declared invalid (previous will or intestate succession applies)
Specific clauses are struck out
The will is upheld and your challenge fails

Executor Problems: What to Do When Things Go Wrong

Sometimes the issue isn't with the will itself, but with how the executor is administering the estate.

Signs of Executor Misconduct

Excessive delays: Estate administration taking years without explanation
No communication: Executor ignores your requests for information
Asset mismanagement: Selling property below value or neglecting investments
Personal benefit: Executor using estate funds for themselves
Ignoring the will: Not following the testator's instructions
Premature distribution: Distributing assets before debts are paid

Your Rights as a Beneficiary

You have the right to:

Receive a copy of the will (once lodged with the Master)
Be informed about estate administration progress
Question valuations if you believe assets are undervalued
Receive an accounting of all estate transactions
Take action against an executor who breaches their duties

Removing a Problem Executor

An executor can be removed under Section 54 of the Administration of Estates Act on grounds including:

Misconduct or negligence
Incapacity (mental or physical)
Gross inefficiency
Dishonesty or fraud
Conviction for theft, fraud, or forgery

The process:

Submit a complaint to the Master of the High Court
If the Master doesn't act, apply to the High Court with evidence
The court may remove the executor and appoint a replacement

Note: Mere disagreements with the executor are not sufficient for removal. You must show serious misconduct or incompetence.

Maintenance Claims: Rights of Spouses and Children

Even if a spouse or child is disinherited, they may still have a maintenance claim against the estate. South African law recognizes that:

A surviving spouse may claim maintenance if the marriage was in community of property or they were dependent
Minor children are entitled to maintenance from their deceased parent's estate
Adult children may have claims in limited circumstances

These claims don't invalidate the will but ensure dependants are provided for.

Costs of Contesting a Will

| Expense Type | Typical Range | |--------------|---------------| | Initial consultation | R1,500 – R3,000 | | Lodging a caveat | R2,000 – R5,000 | | Mediation | R10,000 – R30,000 | | High Court litigation | R50,000 – R500,000+ | | Expert witnesses (forensic, medical) | R10,000 – R50,000 each |

Costs vary significantly based on complexity. Unsuccessful challenges may leave you liable for the other party's legal costs.

FAQ: Contesting a Will in South Africa

How long do I have to contest a will?

There's no fixed time limit, but you should act quickly. Once the estate is wound up and assets distributed, recovery becomes extremely difficult. Lodge a caveat as soon as you identify concerns.

Can I contest a will if I wasn't mentioned in it?

Yes, if you would have inherited under intestate succession (the law that applies when there's no will) or were named in a previous will. You must have legal standing.

What happens to the estate while the will is being contested?

The estate administration is typically paused until the dispute is resolved. This can take months or even years, delaying distribution to all beneficiaries.

Can a verbal promise override a will?

No. Verbal promises about what someone will leave you have no legal effect in South African law. Only a properly executed written will governs inheritance.

Is it worth contesting a will?

It depends on the strength of your grounds, the value of the estate, and your financial resources. Many challenges fail, and costs can be substantial. Get professional legal advice before deciding.

Can the executor and a beneficiary be the same person?

Yes, this is common. However, if the executor-beneficiary acts in their own interest at the expense of other beneficiaries, it could be grounds for removal.

When to Get Legal Help

Consult an estate attorney immediately if:

You believe a will is forged or fraudulent
The testator was suffering from dementia or mental illness
Someone isolated the testator and suddenly benefits greatly
You're a dependent who was completely disinherited
The executor is mismanaging the estate

Concerned About a Will or Estate?

Challenging a will or dealing with executor problems is emotionally difficult and legally complex. The earlier you get professional advice, the better your chances of a fair outcome.

LekkerLaw connects you with verified estate and wills attorneys across Johannesburg, Cape Town, Durban, Pretoria, and all of South Africa. Matching is free, and your information is protected under POPIA.

→ Find an estate attorney near me

Your privacy matters. LekkerLaw complies with POPIA (Protection of Personal Information Act). Your personal information will only be shared with matched attorneys for the purpose of providing legal services.